Rolando Romero Shocks the World: Ryan Garcia's Comeback Disappointed in Times Square Thriller

On a night that re-wrote the script for the welterweight division, Rolando "Rolly" Romero shocked the boxing world by defeating Ryan Garcia in a stunning upset under the neon glow of Times Square. Garcia's anticipated return to the top was a nightmare instead as Romero outboxed, outran, and out-punched the erstwhile star in what is already being considered one of the biggest upsets of 2025.

A Battle That Defied the Odds

Few thought Romero stood any chance realistically going into the bout. Garcia, who had just returned from a 13-month suspension after testing positive for a drug test, was using this bout to shake off ring rust and set himself up for a large payday rematch with Devin Haney. But Romero otherwise.

Off the bell, he employed pressure and poise. In Round 2, he knocked Garcia out with a photo-finish right hand, and the script for the remainder of the fight was written. Garcia never really settled in.

The final scorecards were proof: 115-112, 115-112, and an emphatic 118-109, all in Romero's favor, as he left with the WBA Regular Welterweight Title and a huge career windfall.

Garcia's Comeback Falls Flat

This was not only a loss for Garcia—it was a collapse.

He was hesitant, lead-footed, and lacking the quickness that propelled him onto the web limelight. His punches never left his fists, CompuBox reported; Garcia was able to get away with but 54 punches over 12 rounds—the lowest ever for a championship fight of the complete distance.

Fans were looking for a comeback tale. What they received instead was a cautionary tale in Garcia's comeback.

Haney-Garcia Rematch? Hold On

The biggest casualty of this upset may not be Garcia's ego—it's the forsaken future.

Devin Haney, who just battled to a win over José Ramírez in the co-feature, was set to face Garcia in a blockbuster rematch later this year. That rematch is now pretty much dead and buried, and Romero has placed himself firmly in the running for a title.

Haney vs. Romero is suddenly a very real option—and an upset perhaps that hadn't been expected by the fans.

Times Square Is Turned into a Boxing Mecca

The battle itself was historic in proportions. Hosted by Saudi Arabia's General Entertainment Authority, the battle was held outdoors in Times Square, transforming New York City's iconic crossroads into a gigantic boxing ring.

Thousands of supporters filled the hall, a humming festival atmosphere. With lights glaring and fists aloft, boxing had one of its most theatrical nights ever—and Romero was right in the middle of it.

What's Next?

For Romero: He's got the WBA belt and lots of steam. Is he going to defend his belt against Haney or seek out another top-level challenger?

For Garcia: A very, very long road ahead. His next fight might be make-or-break career time.

For the sport: The welterweight division just got a whole lot more intriguing—and unpredictable.

Final Word

Rolando Romero's victory is not just an upset—it's a wake-up call to everyone writing off underdogs in boxing. As Garcia seeks redemption, Romero gets to bask in a moment that can make his legacy.

And if May 2, 2025, taught us anything, it's this: when it comes to the sport of boxing, the only guarantee is surprise.